November 26., 1943 Almost a disaster in Zuidbroek

Airraid 169 against Bremen
In the early morning of Friday 26. November 1943 440 heavy bombers of the 8. Airforce took off from the American
airbases in Eastern England. The crews were briefed for a raid (raid no. 169) on a very important target, which was already attacked on November 3., 1943, the city of Bremen, the second harbour in Nazi-Germany with about 430,000 inhibitants and his navy dockyards along the river Weser, where the Germans built and repaired there U-boats, who were responsable for the huge loss of ships on the Atlantic. At the end of raid 169 25 of the bombers did not return to their bases in England.

At the going down of the sun and in the morning we will remember them

The flightplans
One of the planes, which was indirectly a victim of the heavy flak above Bremen, was a B-17 F, without a nickname, serial 42-3531, belonging to the 365. Bomb squadron, 305. Bomb group.
It took off from the airfield Chelveston, east of Northampton, England. This plane was manned by:

 - Pilot-Captain 2./Lt. Harold S. Elliot from Osakis, Minnesota
 - Co-pilot 2./Lt. Shelby Pitts from Greensberg, Indiana
 - Navigator 2./Lt. A.W. Hunger from Mount Union, Iowa
 - Bombadier 2./Lt. William A. Staub from Trenton, New Jersey
 - Radioman T./Sgt. Raymond W. Poirier from Franklin County, New York State.
 - Upper turret gunner Engineer T./Sgt. W.P. Mandell from Fairfield County, Connecticut.
 - Left waste gunner S./Sgt. James O. Stiles from Texas
 - Right waste gunner S./Sgt. Edward H. Matte from Massachusetts
 - Ball turret gunner S./Sgt. Kenneth F. Mahood from Pennsylvania
 - Tail gunner S./Sgt. Lawrence M. Mize from Texas

The crew of 42-3531 in 1943

Top row (left to right):
Upper Turret Gunner Engineer - T./Sgt. William P. Mandell
Navigator - 2./Lt. Wickersham was not on 42-3531 flight, replaced by 2./Lt. 
Arnold W. Hunger
Pilot Captain - 2./Lt. Harold S. Elliott
Co-Pilot - 2./Lt. Shelby Pitts
Bombardier - 2./Lt. William A. Staub

Bottom row (left to right):
Tail Gunner - S./Sgt. Harper was not on 42-3531 flight, replaced by S./Sgt 
Lawrence M. Mize
Ball Turret Gunner - S./Sgt. Kenneth F. Mahood
Right Waist Gunner - S./Sgt. Edward H. Matte
Radioman - T./Sgt. Raymond W. Poirier
Left Waist Gunner - S./Sgt. James C. Stiles

The raid
Just after starting the raid the plane, carrying eight 500 lb bombs and 20 M-47, was hit by flak in both outside engines and in the cockpit. The first who was hit was T./Sgt. Raymond W. Poirier. He was hit in one of his legs. After
he reported, Lt. Elliot ordered S./Sgt. Edward H. Matte to help Poirier. Poirier answered that he was not hurt very badly, however he felt blood running against his leg. In spite of the damage, the pilots could stay in formation, so Lt. Staub could drop his bombs on the target as planned.
Shortly after dropping the bombs the plane fell back and became a straggler out of the defence of the formation.
They were noticed by a few ME-109's between Bremen and Groningen. The fighters attacked from position 9 o'clock. S./Sgt. James C. Stiles had a very rough time. His gun failed and he informed S./Sgt. Edward H. Matte about the enemies. Also the ball turret gunner S./Sgt. Kenneth F. Mahood from Pennsylvania was working very hard, afterwards showed out he has used all his ammo.
Immediately the enemy fighter attacked from position 6 o'clock and S/Sgt. Lawrence M. Mize, the tail gunner from Texas had his rough time on 7,000 meters height. The plane couldn't stand those attacks and was damaged all over.
T/Sgt. Mandell was hit in his right leg by a 20 mm. granate. Also Sgt. Mize and Lt. Pitts were wounded. Mize in his left hand and Pitts in his right leg. Afterwards they said there was a fire in the cockpit.
The plane reached the Dutch border and was loosing height. It was flying at about 6,000 meters. Lt. Elliot saw from his place in the cockpit the wounded T/Sgt. Mandell. This sight must have upset him and he decided to help him bailing out, so he could be in hospital very soon. Elliot also left the plane.
Meanwhile Lt. Pitts tried, sitting in the cockpit, to fly the plane at his own. When it showed out that Elliot wouldn't return he switched to automatic pilot and bailed out. Lt. Pitts rang the bail-out alarm bell before he bailed out. The plane was at about 17,000 feet at that time.
Lt. Hunger and Lt. Staub saw him jumping and concluded the plane was given up and bailed out too at about 13,000 feet.
In the back of the plane there were still some men who had no idea what was happening. It is possible that the intercom broke down, so they didn't hear the bail out order. Sgt. Matte, the right waste gunner noticed that the plane slightly was going down, but he thought this was a planned action by the pilot.
On a certain moment they concluded that something was wrong and they had to leave the plane. Sgt. Matte assisted Sgt. Mize by bailing out and after him Sgt. Mahood, Sgt. Stiles and Sgt. Matte jumped off at a height of about 1,000 meters.
After Sgt. Matte landed, a farmer came to him and asked if he he was American or Canadian. He answered he was American. The farmer asked him to follow. Matte thought the farmer was member of the resistance and walked with him to his house. Matte remembers a beautiful blond girl, about 4 years old. He opened his survival kit and gave her some chewing gum. Shortly after he entered the house, a huge man, speaking english very well, arrived. He told
he was Colonel in the Dutch army and he was grounded by the German authorities. Very soon two German soldiers arrived. An older sergeant assisted by a very young soldier. The sergeant left soon and Matte was guarded by the young soldier, who was very friendly. The soldier asked the farmer for a map of the USA. The soldier searched on the map and pointed on a city in Michigan. The colonel told the soldier had an uncle living in that city.
The sergeant returned with a little car. The parachute of Matte in the back. He envited Matte to sit down in the back and drove away. After about half an hour they arrived at a military site, obviously an anti-aircraftgun. It was almost dark so Matte couldn't observe the site from his position. After a meal he went to sleep. He must slept for almost an hour, when twelve German soldiers entered, surrounding him. The officer in duty made a sign with his finger over his throat and Matte concluded they'll kill him when he tried to escape.
Later a car arrived. When Matte looked outside, he saw a truck and as a surprise he saw the other crew members except Mandell and Mahood, who arrived earlier. After a while they took Matte and his friends outside. They had to step into the truck and they were driven to the Roman Catholic Hospital in Groningen. Mize and Pitts had to stay there. The other men were transported to the navy prison in Groningen, where they spent the night of 26/27
November. The next day they travelled by train the whole day and spent the night in a German city.

The crash
At about 1300 hours the fortress, which was given up by it's crew crashed in Zuidbroek. While coming down it passed the villages of Veendam and Muntendam. Harry Venema, 13 years old at that time said: On that day I was, before I went to school, playing outside. At about 1300 hours I heard the sound of a plane, a flying fortress, on a height of about 200 meters, damaged as I could see and the speed was too low. Suddenly I saw another plane, a German fighter, that flew around the bomber. But there was no shooting. Also I saw about five parachutes in the
air. Meanwhile the plane turned to a northern course and I could follow it till it passed Muntendam. Later on I saw a huge cloud of smoke.
In Zuidbroek the local baker E. Meijer, was frightened to death when he saw the crashing plane right in front of him. The plane hit the ground after crossing the Winschoterdiep, a canal, and destroyed the houses of the Nijhof and the Op de Dijk family. It just missed the school by meters. The houses were completely damaged and the burning wreck laid on the land owned by farmer J.J. Krans. The oldest daughter of the Op de Dijk family and Mr. Nijhof were lightly hurt. The daughter of Nijhof laid behind their house uncounsious. She was taken to a hospital and recovered. Soon German soldiers and police came to secure the area. Later they found the burned body of T./Sgt. Raymond W.
Poirier, who was first buried November 29.,1943 in Zuidboek.
After the war on February 14., 1949 his body is reburied on the Netherlands American Cemetery in Margraten. (plotno.7 row 10 grave 14).

The grave of Raymond W. Poirier

Prisoners of war
The men who survived the crash were caught by the Germans.
T./Sgt. Mandell who was seriously enjured was taken to a hospital in Groningen where he died November 29., 1943.
They others were transported to the navy prison in the city of Groningen, where they spent the night of 26/27 November. The next day they were transported to prisoner camps. Elliott, Pitts, Hunger and Staub were interned in Stalag Luft 1 in Barth, Germany in barracks 2, room 4 of the south compound of this camp.
The other three men, Stiles, Matte and Mahood, were interned in Stalag 17B in Braunau-Gneikendorf
near Krems, Austria. Where Wise was taken to prison is not known.

Prisoner of war ID of William A. Staub


The Boeing B-17 "Flying Fortress"

The Flying Fortress is one of the most famous airplanes in World War II. The prototype first flew in 1935. From late 1941 it was on service. The plane served in almost every battlezone of World War II, but is best known for the strategic daylight bombing of German industrial targets.
During the production the plane was modified several times. The plane got the name "Flying fortress" for his strong armour and his heavy arms (13 machine guns calibre 0.50). His topspeed was 480 Km/h. It was capable even heavely damaged to return to the homebase. The production of this plane ended 1945 after a total of 12,726 built planes.

B-17 Flying Fortresses in action


Additional information about the crewmembers (Updated until September 15., 2012)
2./Lt. Harold Seymour Elliot, died January 20., 2005 Buchanan Dam, Texas (USA)
2./Lt. Shelby Pitts, died July 1983, Danville, California (USA)
2./Lt. Arnold Wallace Hunger, died December 19., 1990, Mount Union, Iowa (USA)
2./Lt. William Ambrose Staub, lives in Virginia (USA)
T./Sgt. Raymond W. Poirier, died in combat November 26., 1943. Buried in the Netherlands (see text)
T./Sgt. William P. Mandell, died in combat November 29., 1943. His gravesite is not known by us
S./Sgt. James Oliver Stiles, died January 10., 2009, Louisville, Kentucky (USA)
S./Sgt. Edward Henry Matte, he left the service on February 28, 1973, died May 21., 2004, Colorado Springs, Colorado (USA)
S./Sgt. Kenneth Frank Mahood, died May 6., 1997, Portersville, Pennsylvania (USA)
S./Sgt. Lawrence Mintren Mise, died September 23., 2009, Hemet, California (USA)

Sources to this story:

Ab A. Jansen "Sporen aan de hemel" (3 parts)
H. Antonides "Noord- en Zuidbroek in vroeger jaren"

Gemeentearchief gemeente Menterwolde in Muntendam
National Archives, Washington DC, USA

Special thanks to:
Lt. William A. Staub and his children Mildred and Bryan, who sent me additional information and photos.
John D. Bowen, Silver Spring, Maryland, USA for researching the National Archives, Washington DC. Without his help I wasn't been able to complete this article.
Riiren Belsuo, who gave me additional information.